Virginia Apgar, a pioneering figure in medicine, is best known for developing the Apgar Score in 1952, a quick and simple method to assess the health of newborns immediately after birth. Her contributions revolutionized neonatal care and have saved countless lives across the globe. The Apgar Score, which assesses a baby’s heart rate, respiration, muscle tone, reflexes, and color, remains in use today, providing critical early intervention when needed.
Apgar developed this scoring system to address a major issue she saw in delivery rooms: the lack of a standardized method to evaluate newborns immediately after birth. As an anesthesiologist, she noticed that newborns, especially those affected by anesthesia or other complications during labor, were often not assessed quickly enough, leading to delays in care. Doctors were primarily focused on the mother’s condition during delivery, and sometimes newborns with issues went unnoticed until it was too late. Apgar recognized the need for a simple, systematic way to evaluate a baby’s condition immediately after birth to ensure prompt treatment if needed.
The Apgar Score allowed healthcare providers to assess a baby’s health within the first minute and again at five minutes after birth. By creating an easy-to-use system based on five criteria (heart rate, respiratory effort, muscle tone, reflex irritability, and skin color), Apgar made it possible to quickly identify babies in distress and intervene before it was too late. Her work changed the way newborns were treated in the critical moments after birth, dramatically improving survival rates and preventing long-term health issues.
Her accomplishments didn’t stop there. Dr. Apgar worked for the March of Dimes, focusing on birth defects and advocating for greater research and prevention efforts. Her work in this area highlighted her dedication to improving maternal and infant health and her ongoing commitment to education and advocacy.
Virginia Apgar’s groundbreaking work in neonatology and anesthesiology is particularly significant because it came during a time when women were often excluded from leadership roles in medicine. Despite the challenges, she rose to prominence, earning her place as a trailblazer and a hero in healthcare.
Controversies:
While Virginia Apgar’s contributions to neonatology are widely celebrated, the Apgar Score has sparked some controversy, particularly as its use has evolved over time. The score was initially designed to assess a newborn’s immediate health and survival during the neonatal period, but it has at times been misused or overextended to predict outcomes it was never intended to evaluate, such as long-term neurologic development and birth asphyxia. Critics argue that it should not be relied upon solely for these purposes, as other factors like preterm birth, congenital anomalies, or medications given to the mother can also affect the score.
Some concerns center around the subjective nature of the Apgar Score. While it provides important physiological insights, it is only a snapshot of a newborn’s condition at a single point in time and relies on subjective assessment of skin tone, muscle tone, and reflexes. In particular, the use of skin tone as one of the criteria has been criticized by some as potentially discriminatory, as it may not account for the natural variations in skin color that exist across different populations.
There is also debate over whether the score has become outdated in the face of modern neonatal care and resuscitation techniques. Some argue that while the Apgar Score remains a valuable tool, it should be used in conjunction with more advanced measures such as umbilical-artery blood pH to more accurately assess a newborn’s condition.
Another point of discussion is the potential bias in how the Apgar Score is applied. Studies have suggested that newborns delivered by midwives or certified nurse-midwives, particularly in birth centers or home births, are more likely to receive a perfect score of 10 at five minutes, which raises questions about consistency in scoring across different birth settings.
Despite these concerns, the Apgar Score continues to be a widely-used and important tool in neonatal care. While it may have limitations, especially when used in isolation, it remains a valuable method for assessing the need for immediate medical attention after birth. Virginia Apgar’s legacy is not diminished by these critiques, but rather enriched by the ongoing discussion of how her work can be improved and adapted to better serve newborns and their families.
In Her Own Words:
Virginia Apgar was a woman of action, and her words reflected her forward-thinking approach to both medicine and life:
- “Nobody, but nobody, is going to stop breathing on me!”
- This statement exemplified Apgar’s no-nonsense approach to neonatal care, underscoring her determination to ensure that newborns received the immediate attention they needed to survive.
- “Women are liberated from the time they leave the womb!”
- Apgar was a vocal advocate for women’s empowerment, speaking to the inherent strength of women and the role they should play in shaping their own destinies.
- “If you want to do something, do it. You can’t be sure you’ll live long enough to do it later.”
- This quote encapsulates Apgar’s philosophy of action and ambition, motivating countless women to push past societal boundaries and seize opportunities.
Her Lasting Legacy:
Virginia Apgar’s legacy is nothing short of revolutionary. The Apgar Score is still used globally in delivery rooms, a testament to her innovation and dedication. It is rare that a single medical advancement remains so widely used for decades, but Apgar’s work was truly ahead of its time.
Her career with the March of Dimes helped reshape the focus of maternal and infant health, leading to expanded research on congenital disorders and birth defects. Apgar’s tireless advocacy in this field led to significant advances in prenatal care and early intervention strategies, improving the lives of millions of families.
Her pioneering role as a woman in medicine continues to inspire generations of women pursuing careers in science and healthcare. Apgar demonstrated that no dream is too big and no goal is too ambitious, blazing trails that others continue to follow.
Personal Reflections:
I admire Virginia Apgar’s bravery and her relentless drive to innovate, even when the odds were stacked against her. As a woman in medicine, she paved the way for so many of us, and her determination to improve the lives of newborns through practical, evidence-based care resonates deeply with my own philosophy as a midwife. Her work with the Apgar Score reminds me that sometimes, the simplest interventions can save lives. This dedication to maternal and infant health is something I strive to emulate in my own practice.
In my work, we assign an Apgar Score to every baby born at my practice, which means her legacy directly impacts me and the care I provide. The fact that her scoring system is still in use speaks volumes to the strength of her work.
It’s also worth mentioning that Apgar’s advocacy for research into congenital disabilities aligns with my own passion for educating and empowering families through evidence-based practices. I respect her deeply for recognizing the importance of both maternal and newborn health as intertwined aspects of care.
Explore More About Virginia Apgar:
- Apgar Score – Wikipedia
- Virginia Apgar – Wikipedia
- Virginia Apgar: Innovative Female Physician and Inventor of the Apgar Score (Women Hall of Famers in Mathematics and Science)
- Ten Women Who Changed Science and the World
- National Library of Medicine: Apgar’s Contributions
Note: Full disclosure: I earn a small (very small) commission on any links that take you to Amazon.